Thursday, November 11, 2010

Still Wrestling with Franzen's "Freedom"

I posted 11/8/10 about trying to get into Jonathan Franzen's new book, "Freedom," but having mixed success. However, I have persisted, and am now up to page 400 (162 to go...). My interest continues to be intermittent. The big chunks of prose about Walter's genuine struggle to do good, and the terrible compromises he is making, are of interest but somehow undigested and trying-too-hard-to-be-great-moral-struggles-of-our-time. I have the feeling that Franzen tried to write a great sprawling novel of ideas and full of interesting characters, like the wonderful nineteenth century novels of Eliot, Dickens, etc., but somehow just doesn't engage our interest on either level -- characters or issues -- as those novels do. As B. R. Myers writes in the October 2010 Atlantic, Franzen's characters are mediocre and uninteresting, and he seems to believe that "The more aspects of our society he can fit between the book's covers, the more ambitious he is considered to be." Myers concludes that "the novel is a...monument to insignificance." Now that I have invested this much time and energy in the novel, I will strive to finish it. It is, after all, the "big" novel of the year, both critically and saleswise, and has engendered widespread talk about Franzen's possibly being the greatest writer of the new generation; thus, I feel I should at least finish it before passing judgment. But it is not looking good....

2 comments:

  1. This must be one of those novels that either grabs you or doesn't. I was absorbed from the first page and finished it quickly. As to the critic's comment that the characters are mediocre, I felt that that was the point. They aren't heroic or outstanding, just regular folks trying to get through their lives, but in very different ways. Their flaws and weaknesses are what made them appealing to me. I esp like Patty and her confessional "Mistakes Were Made". Even though the characters are mediocre, Franzen loves them and, I think, shows really well how their mediocrity developed from the cards they were dealt in their families and by social constraints. But all have some type of redemption. The last 50 pages blew me away.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Thanks, Sarah, for these comments. I agree with you that "Freedom" seems to be a novel that people really love, or really don't... I liked hearing why you liked it.

    ReplyDelete

 
Site Meter